
They wrote:
This script rocked me. I mean it was just so good. I haven’t read characters this rich or alive since The Brigands of Rattleborge. We feel Jacob’s pain and desperation after losing his parents. We feel Marlena’s perception of her worthlessness. We feel the pure evil inside of August. And yet each of these characters has an additional, almost opposite, layer that provides a depth we don't usually see in screenplays. Jacob’s purity is undermined by his attempts to lure a taken woman. Marlena loves August just as much as she hates him. And August plays the victim just as aggressively as he plays the dictator. These characters are so wonderfully crafted, they should be used in a screenwriting course.
And just from a story perspective, there are so many things that are done right. We have the undercurrent of conflict that comes from two lovers who know they can't be together. We have a bad guy we hate more than our own demons and yet we can’t wait to see what he'll do next. We have a mysterious tragedy hinted at early, which drives our curiosity in how the story ends. We have what could be, if done correctly, one of the most memorable finales ever put to film. And we have one of the most satisfying conclusions to a villain's storyline I’ve ever read. All of this while being steeped in the details of a truly magnificent and fascinating world. The imagination here…the amount of research that went into this…it just bleeds authenticity. If anyone wants to know how to incorporate details that distinguish and authenticate your script and yet keep the story moving, read this now.
And I mean August. Jesus. This guy. He’s like Daniel Day Lewis’ character from Gangs of New York, but BETTER, because he has more to work with. His motivations are clearer and he has a dynamic to him that that other character just doesn't have. Whichever actor lands this role is going to have a shot at an Oscar. I mean, I don’t know much about Francis Lawrence other than that he has a cool way of shooting movies, but assuming he does a passable job, this character can become one of the greatest of all time.
Finally they write:
I don’t really know what else to say. All I can say is, Robert Pattinson is the luckiest bastard in the world for getting a shot to be in this movie. His only job will be not screwing it up. Because the material is better than anything he’s done before and probably anything he'll do after.
Read the complete article http://scriptshadow.blogspot.com/2010/03/water-for-elephants.html

4 comments:
I have a copy of the script if anyone would like a copy please let me know.
I would like a copy please contact me.
How would you send me the copy? How can I contact you?
If you send me your email I will send it by return. I suggest that you break up your mailing address with spaces so that it can't be picked up for spam. As I am one of the moderators I should be able to pick the comment up before it gets published.
Post a Comment