The original title of the book written by Sara Gruen is “Water for Elephants” however there is some debate that it might get changed to “Circus” for the film. Certainly the title “Circus” is not very original; I personally feel that leaving the title as it is in the book is the right way forward. Time will tell and nearer the time of filming we should know something definite about what has been decided.


I’m taking this blog very seriously and unless I find confirmation of something, I am not posting. I want this to be for those who really love the story and hopefully the film, so there will be no “hot news” no speculation and it will be dedicated 100% to Water for Elephants. However there will be spoilers so if you have not read the book and don’t want spoilers, then please don’t read this blog.



Sunday, 21 March 2010

Which actor plays what and are they the right ones for the part.

I  read the article (Hollywood Exclusive, by Marilyn Beck and Stacy Jenel Smith) mentioning that they suggest the casting team is looking for an old Jacob Jankowski. May be they are right, I would think it is far more logical that they use a different actor for the part of old Jacob; such was done in “The Notebook.” Ryan Gosling played the young Noah and James Garner as the elderly Noah; I leave it to each individual to suggest their favorite actor for the part.

I start to have my doubts that these two ladies have really read and studied “Water for Elephants” especially when they say that another villain in the story has yet to be cast. Hmmmmmmm as far as I can see, well read in the script, Uncle Al does not exist in the film, so maybe that is why he has not been cast to date.













I would love to hear your comments about the actors that have been cast for the parts; I have read on several blogs that some think Reese Witherspoon is too old for the part of Marlena?

In my humble opinion, taking into account that Jacob is 23, Marlena is 21 and August is 33 then both Reese and Christoph are rather over aged for the parts, they are using a 24 year old Robert Pattinson for the part of Jacob which fits, so either they should have picked a slightly older actor for Jacob or come down a few years in their choice for Marlena and August. Needless to say we may be in for some surprises and changes before the filming gets to start around the 22nd of May.

Please post your comments below.

4 comments:

Mar56 said...

Well I really like Reese and think she will be perfect as Marlena. I,m not so sure about Rob. Christoph Waltz 100% yes, I'm sure he will be great as August.

Unicepd said...

Well I think that Reese Witherspoon is to old, come on she is 34 or 35 years old, how can she play the part of a 21 year old. RobPattz is hot for the part of Jacob and Christoph W could be ok as August, I wonder who will play Walter?

ivyathome said...

I can't wait til they start filming. I like them all and think this is going to be cool.

annie555 said...

When I was reading the book, I pictured Walter as Jordan Prentice. I think would be great as Walter.