The original title of the book written by Sara Gruen is “Water for Elephants” however there is some debate that it might get changed to “Circus” for the film. Certainly the title “Circus” is not very original; I personally feel that leaving the title as it is in the book is the right way forward. Time will tell and nearer the time of filming we should know something definite about what has been decided.


I’m taking this blog very seriously and unless I find confirmation of something, I am not posting. I want this to be for those who really love the story and hopefully the film, so there will be no “hot news” no speculation and it will be dedicated 100% to Water for Elephants. However there will be spoilers so if you have not read the book and don’t want spoilers, then please don’t read this blog.



Saturday, 24 April 2010

Review of Water for Elephants on Audio book, Excelent

Circus train, Foley & Burk. Photographed: San Luis Obispo, Cal., July 26, 1937

I have read the book twice, I have read both scripts that are available, but just like any busy Mum I’ve always lots to do and little time to sit down and read.


With Mother’s day coming up I decided to take a look and see if I could find Water for Elephants as an audio book, luckily I found It was available, so yesterday I bought a copy on behalf of my daughter. Ok I know Mothers day is a week away but I couldn’t wait.

If I enjoyed reading the book and scripts they had nothing on this, listening to the story being told by John Randolph Jones portraying the older Jacob and David LeDoux as the younger Jacob puts an entirely different perspective on the whole story. I found myself with tears in my eyes from minute 7, which is when old Jacob is remembering his deceased wife. I had read this before but the feeling that he put into his voice made it so much more realistic and emotional. The audio book lasts just over 10 hours; it can be downloaded to your computer, MP3, ipod and several other options so everyone should find exactly what they want.

I have a number of audio books and enjoy listening to them when I am busy around the garden or doing household chores, but never have I enjoyed one as much as this. I highly recommend obtaining a copy. I am sure that the film is going to be great, but I truly believe that this audio book will beat the film as it is still 100% the novel, whereas the length of a film limits in somewhat the details included.

By the way if you go through Amazon.com to Audible.com I found that the purchase of a copy was slightly cheaper. If it is any help to you click on the Water for Elephants book advertised on this page (but on the picture) otherwise only the paper book comes up.

Let me know if you get a copy and what you think, I’m sure you'll agree that it is wonderful and well worth listening to time and time again.
















Copyright; This photograph (Top) is from the collection of the photographs of the late Otto Perry (b.1894, d.1970) held at the Western History Department of the Denver Public Library

1 comments:

elaineuk said...

I didn't know that these books existed. What a good idea.