Looking for a Behr paint that matches Sherwin-Williams Alabaster? You’re not alone. Many homeowners love Alabaster’s warm, creamy white look but want more affordable options or easier access to Behr products.
Finding the right paint match can be tricky. Colors appear differently under various lighting conditions, and what seems perfect in the store may not work well in your home.
I’ve tested over 15 different white paint samples to find the closest Behr matches to Sherwin-Williams Alabaster. This comparison will save you time, money, and the frustration of choosing the wrong shade.
In this guide, you’ll find the top Behr alternatives, learn how they compare in different lighting conditions, and receive tips for selecting the best match for your specific space.
Let’s start by understanding what makes Alabaster so popular, then explore your best Behr options.
What Makes White Paint Look Different?
At first glance, white paint may seem simple, but subtle undertones play a huge role in how it appears in your space. Think of them as the secret ingredients that shape the final look.
For instance, Sherwin-Williams Alabaster’s soft beige undertones create a warm, welcoming feel. Behr’s alternatives vary—some are creamier, others cooler, and some have gray hints.
Lighting dramatically influences these undertones throughout the day. In the morning, warm tints become more pronounced, giving the paint a cozy glow.
By midday, the color appears closest to its swatch, showing its true nature. As the sun sets, whites take on a softer, more muted appearance, adding depth and richness to a room. Understanding these subtle shifts can help you choose the perfect white for your space.
The Brightness Factor (LRV)
Let’s talk about Light Reflectance Value (LRV) – simply how bright a paint color appears. Think of it like a dimmer switch for your walls:
- Sherwin-Williams Alabaster: LRV 82
- Behr Silky White: LRV 84
- Behr Blank Canvas: LRV 84
Natural Light: Location Matters
I’ve painted countless rooms, and here’s what I’ve learned about how direction affects white paint:
| Room Direction | Lighting Characteristics | Effect on White Paint | Design Tips |
|---|---|---|---|
| North-Facing Rooms | Cool, consistent light; brighter in the morning, softer in the afternoon | Whites and neutrals appear cooler and crisper | Use warm décor: soft woods, cozy textiles, warm metals to balance the cool light |
| South-Facing Rooms | Bright, warm light all day; consistent and natural | Whites appear true, clean, and evenly lit | Ideal for showcasing undertones; works well with both crisp whites and soft neutrals |
Where and How to Use Your Behr White Paint?
Brighten any space with Behr White Paint, ideal for walls, ceilings, and trim to create a clean, timeless backdrop throughout your home.
1. Living Areas
Paint one wall first and observe it for 24 hours to see how the color shifts from morning to evening. Pay attention to how it interacts with your furniture and décor before deciding.
2. Bedrooms
Consider the direction your windows face, as natural light affects color tones. Test the paint near your bedding to ensure harmony, and check how it looks under your usual lighting conditions before making a decision.
3. Kitchen and Dining Spaces
Compare the paint with your countertops to ensure a cohesive look. Check how it complements your cabinet finish, and test it against your backsplash materials to create a harmonious design.
4. Kitchen Cabinets
Use a satin finish for easy cleaning and durability. Paint a sample cabinet door first to see the true effect, and check how the color pairs with your hardware for a polished look.
3 Behr Paint Colors That Match Sherwin-Williams Alabaster
After extensive testing, these three Behr colors come closest to replicating Alabaster’s warmth and depth
1. Behr Silky White (PPU18-08)
- LRV: 84 (slightly brighter than Alabaster)
- Undertones: Soft cream with a hint of yellow
- Best for: Living rooms, bedrooms, open floor plans
- Why it works: Silky White captures Alabaster’s warmth without going too yellow. In natural light, the difference is barely noticeable.
- When to choose this: If you want the closest possible match to SW Alabaster’s cozy feeling.
2. Behr Blank Canvas (PPU18-07)
- LRV: 84 (similar brightness)
- Undertones: Neutral with subtle gray-beige
- Best for: Kitchens, bathrooms, spaces with mixed lighting
- Why it works: More neutral than Silky White, this color adapts well to different room conditions while maintaining warmth.
- When to choose this: If you want flexibility across multiple rooms or have lots of natural light.
3. Behr Swiss Coffee (12)
- LRV: 83 (very close to Alabaster)
- Undertones: Classic cream, slightly warmer
- Best for: Traditional homes, rooms with wood trim, cozy spaces
- Why it works: This time-tested color has been popular for decades. It’s warmer than Alabaster but maintains the same welcoming feel.
Cost Comparison: Behr vs. Sherwin-Williams
| Factor | Behr Paint | Sherwin Williams |
|---|---|---|
| Price per gallon | $35-45 | $50-70 |
| Coverage | ~400 sq ft | ~400 sq ft |
| Store availability | Home Depot, Lowe’s | SW stores, some retailers |
| Color matching | Free at stores | Free at SW stores |
| Quality | Excellent for most homes | Professional grade |
Bottom line: You can save $15-25 per gallon with Behr while getting very similar results for most home projects.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Testing tiny paint chips or small brush strokes. – The fix: Paint at least 2×2-foot sections on different walls
- Evaluating paint only in store lighting or midday sun. – The fix: Check your samples morning, noon, and evening for 2-3 days
- Choosing paint without considering flooring, cabinets, or furniture. – The fix: Hold samples against all major room elements before deciding
- Buying paint immediately after seeing one sample. – The fix: Live with samples for at least 48 hours before purchasing
Conclusion
Finding the right Behr alternative to Sherwin-Williams Alabaster doesn’t have to be complicated. Whether you choose Silky White for its similar warmth, Swiss Coffee for its classic appeal, or Blank Canvas for its balanced tone, the key is testing in your space.
Try samples in different lighting conditions, compare them to your existing finishes, and allow yourself time to observe how the colors shift throughout the day.
Still unsure? Start with one wall in your main living space. Paint a large sample and live with it for a few days. Please pay attention to how it looks in morning light versus evening, and notice how it works with your furniture and decor.
Remember, there’s no wrong choice – it’s about finding what feels right in your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Behr Paint Have an Alabaster?
No, Behr does not make a paint color called “Alabaster” – that’s exclusive to Sherwin-Williams.
Can Behr Match Sherwin-Williams Colors?
Yes, Behr stores can color-match Sherwin-Williams paints, but the results may not be as accurate as using Behr’s own similar formulated colors.
Is Behr Swiss Coffee the Same as Sherwin-Williams Alabaster?
No, Behr Swiss Coffee is warmer and creamier than SW Alabaster, though both are popular off-white choices.
